Keynote thoughts: Time Capsule, Macbook Air
We have to admit that the Macbook Air is a beautiful machine. It makes holding a laptop as little effort as holding an iPhone. Pricewise, it’s pretty good – £1199 for the 1.6GHz version. Battery life at five hours isn’t shabby either. The construction is simply beautifully clever. But it’s all show and no go.
Firstly, you can’t upgrade the memory. The solid-state hard disk adds a lot of cost – £639, and there’s no telling how long it will last. Solid state memory has a finite read-write cycle.
(incidentally, that means the secondhand value of machines with solid-state memory will be poor. How long can you predict it will last?)
But my main issue with them is that they’re not robust. Strength has definitely been compromised in favour of lightness. The body clearly flexes when you press on it even gently. (The Apple demonstrator watching me do this had a look of undisguised horror on her face.)
Sure, you can wrap it in a robust case of plastic or metal. Which will add the weight back and leave you with a poor performance to weight ratio. If you do that, you may as well have bought a Macbook Pro.
If style over substance matters – buy the Macbook Air. It is beautiful. It will sit perfectly on paper-free desks in gorgeously minimalist offices. If you need a machine on which to get your work done, get a Macbook Pro instead.
The Time Capsule is fairly useful in very small businesses. The combination of wireless router and Time Machine backup disk is good. I hope a software update to existing Airport Expresses will allow USB disks to be used as easily – there’s no reason why that shouldn’t happen. It was the one update that wasn’t explicitly mentioned in the Keynote though. We’ll see.
Technorati Tags:
Macbook Air, Macbook Pro, Apple, MacWorld
Posted: January 15th, 2008 under Comment.
Comments: 1